*These thoughts are my own and in no way claim to represent Dr. Sell’s views.
Do you remember Dr. Sell’s flowchart? Do you remember which box he (and Frankena) thinks is most important? That’s right, Box C – the profile of what you want to produce. I think that Dr. Sell makes a great case for us to think through what maturity in our organizations ought to look like. I think he’s also right to call out the “bait and switch” in the contemporary church model that fixates on “felt needs” instead of thinking about discipleship.
But, as I sat pondering the importance of Box C, I began to wonder whether students typically think of what kind of person they want to produce or what kind of community we want to produce. Obviously, we don’t have to choose between developing people and communities. But isn’t the Scripture replete with statements about what the people of God ought to be? Individualistically, we can look to vice and virtue lists. Communally, we can look to passages like Matthew 5:14 (city set upon a hill). For the two aspects presented in tension, we can look to Ephesians 4:1-13. It doesn’t seem optional for us to grapple with the profile of the community we want to produce.
And here’s the rub: If the question of ethnic diversity never crosses our mind, it seems to me that we resign ourselves to whatever racial demographic ends up resulting – and let’s face it… that usually means homogeneity. Is that ok? Let me put it another way: If we feel free to leave Isaiah 56:7 (“house of prayer for all nations”) out of Box C do we not miss something that Jesus desires for his Church (Mark 11:17)?
There may be problems that I haven’t seen with putting a communal spin on Box C. And I know that this is more complicated for churches in, say, North Dakota. But I thought I should ask us. I’m eager for your feedback!
But, as I sat pondering the importance of Box C, I began to wonder whether students typically think of what kind of person they want to produce or what kind of community we want to produce. Obviously, we don’t have to choose between developing people and communities. But isn’t the Scripture replete with statements about what the people of God ought to be? Individualistically, we can look to vice and virtue lists. Communally, we can look to passages like Matthew 5:14 (city set upon a hill). For the two aspects presented in tension, we can look to Ephesians 4:1-13. It doesn’t seem optional for us to grapple with the profile of the community we want to produce.
And here’s the rub: If the question of ethnic diversity never crosses our mind, it seems to me that we resign ourselves to whatever racial demographic ends up resulting – and let’s face it… that usually means homogeneity. Is that ok? Let me put it another way: If we feel free to leave Isaiah 56:7 (“house of prayer for all nations”) out of Box C do we not miss something that Jesus desires for his Church (Mark 11:17)?
There may be problems that I haven’t seen with putting a communal spin on Box C. And I know that this is more complicated for churches in, say, North Dakota. But I thought I should ask us. I’m eager for your feedback!